Christine Benvenuto - Sex Changes

2012, Christine Benvenuto, English, Joy Ladin,

Full title: "Sex Changes: A Memoir of Marriage, Gender, and Moving On" by Christine Benvenuto.

In Sex Changes: A Memoir of Marriage, Gender, and Moving On, Christine Benvenuto confronts the question that most people never imagine asking: What happens when the other woman is your husband? This searing, darkly humorous, and emotionally raw memoir invites us into the inner sanctum of a marriage disrupted not by infidelity, but by transformation,when Benvenuto’s husband of over two decades comes out as a transgender woman.

 

One night, as they lay in bed in their New England home, the father of her three children says, “I’m thinking constantly about my gender.” From that moment, the landscape of Christine’s life shifts irreversibly. What follows is not just the dissolution of a marriage, but the dismantling of identity, family roles, social expectations, and deeply rooted assumptions about love, gender, and the self. Unlike many transgender memoirs that chart the joy and struggle of transitioning, Sex Changes is told from the other side of the mirror. Benvenuto writes as the cisgender spouse, blindsided, heartbroken, and profoundly confused. She offers no sanitized narrative of easy acceptance, nor does she demonize her former partner. Instead, she chronicles a process of grief and reassembly. 

 

As the woman she once knew as her husband slowly disappears, Benvenuto finds herself unexpectedly single, the sole caregiver to three children, and navigating the murky waters of small-town curiosity, transphobia, and loneliness. At times, her prose bristles with bitterness. At others, it softens with self-deprecating wit. She jokes about telling neighbors that her spouse was simply “experimenting with fashion” when heels began accompanying neckties. She reflects on the absurdities of the situation: the new awkwardness of co-parenting with a woman she no longer recognizes, the disorienting emotional betrayal she feels, and the slow, painful birth of a new self that must emerge from the wreckage.

What makes Sex Changes so compelling is its refusal to play nicely with the neat narratives often expected of allies. Benvenuto does not claim sainthood. She does not claim to understand her ex’s experience, nor does she try to justify her own pain away. She mourns the loss of the man she loved and is candid about how hard it was to accept that that man never truly existed, at least not in the way she thought. The story becomes less about Christine’s former partner, Joy Ladin, now a distinguished poet and theologian, and more about Christine’s own journey to reclaim her life. In this way, the memoir pairs hauntingly with Ladin’s own work, especially her memoir Through the Door of Life: A Jewish Journey Between Genders, and her poetic explorations of identity and divine encounter. Ladin’s story is one of transcending a lifelong cage of falsehood. In the 2014 interview with The Heroines, Ladin talks about the years of hiding and the agony of living a life as someone she was not. Her language is poetic, generous, even reverent: “[Coming out] was the first time I could breathe without a lie.” For Joy, the transition is a spiritual resurrection. For Christine, it is a kind of crucifixion.

 

The contrast between these narratives is not about right and wrong, but about perspective. If Joy’s journey is a coming-into-being, Christine’s is a surviving-the-aftermath. As Joy reclaims herself, Christine is left to rebuild the scaffolding of a life she thought she knew. Both women are telling the truth, theirs. To read Sex Changes is to be reminded that queerness does not exist in isolation. Every identity shift reverberates outward. In queer and trans literature, the focus is understandably on the individual coming out or transitioning. But Benvenuto’s book stands out for daring to document the collateral emotional terrain, not to diminish her ex-partner’s liberation, but to validate her own emotional truths. Some critics have taken issue with the memoir’s tone, pointing out moments where Benvenuto’s confusion veers into resentment or where the pain of her loss seems to cast a shadow over her support for her former spouse’s transition. But this is precisely what makes the memoir so powerful. It’s not tidy. It’s not PR-friendly. It’s honest. In fact, Benvenuto’s writing echoes some of the discomfort Joy Ladin expressed in her interview: “The hardest part was knowing that in becoming myself, I was destroying the life my family had counted on.” That self-awareness, the knowledge that authenticity can sometimes hurt others, is what binds these two women together, even as they’ve grown apart.

 

What emerges in Sex Changes is not a polemic about transgender rights or a treatise on identity politics. It is instead a very human story about the wreckage and rebirth of love, about how two people can mean the world to each other and still find themselves on irreconcilable paths. Benvenuto ultimately finds solace not in understanding, but in rebuilding. She rediscovers friendship, self-worth, and the power of single motherhood. She tells us that we don’t have to fully understand someone to honor their truth, but we can still grieve what their truth takes away from us. Her story invites us to hold contradictory feelings in our hands, to support trans rights while also acknowledging that those transitions can break hearts, families, and identities. It is a memoir of moving on without forgetting, of laughing through tears, of carrying children and loss at the same time. As Joy Ladin herself wrote in one of her poems, “Transition is never just a step forward. It’s always a falling, a letting go.” Christine Benvenuto fell hard, but in Sex Changes, she shows us how she found the ground again.

Available via Amazon

 

Other related sources: