In Gender Outlaw: On Men, Women, and the Rest of Us, Kate Bornstein delivers a manifesto, a memoir, and a performance all at once, blowing up gender categories with laughter, wit, and razor-sharp critique. First published in 1994 and now regarded as a foundational work in queer theory and trans literature, Gender Outlaw captures the intimate reflections of a person who has lived across and beyond the binary, challenging the assumptions that sex, gender, and desire must conform to cultural expectations.
Bornstein, a former heterosexual man, IBM salesman, and high-ranking Scientologist, later transitioned into a lesbian woman and eventually stepped outside the confines of binary gender entirely. In a 2017 interview with The Heroines blog, Bornstein recalled that writing Gender Outlaw was an attempt “to make peace with the world that hated me, and with myself for internalizing that hatred.” That vulnerability, combined with an irreverent theatricality, defines the book’s unique power.
Gender Outlaw is structured like a performance piece, mixing traditional prose with dialogues, scripts, and excerpts from her play Hidden: A Gender. This fragmented structure mirrors the fluidity of gender itself. It also draws on her theatrical background, infusing the work with drama, humor, and occasional absurdity. The stage becomes her workplace, and her life becomes both the script and the revolution.
This observation, far from abstract, speaks directly to the oppressive systems that shape our lives from birth. The “gender defenders,” as she calls them, are those who rigidly maintain this binary, often at the expense of anyone who does not fit within its confines.
Through this lens, Bornstein critiques not only heteronormativity but also the early trans narrative that every trans woman must be “a woman trapped in a man’s body.” That story, she explains in The Heroines interview, never fit her, and it still doesn’t. She transitioned because the world offered only two options, not because she felt entirely at home in either.
About a third of the book is devoted to queer theater, especially Hidden: A Gender, which dramatizes the life of Herculine Barbin, a 19th-century intersex person whose diaries fascinated Foucault. Through performance, Bornstein explores the "in-between" spaces of gender, not to resolve them, but to inhabit them more fully.
In her interview with The Heroines, Bornstein said theater gave her a place “to tell the truth through lies,” to embrace contradiction rather than simplify it.
This is true of Gender Outlaw as well, which plays with narrative form and confronts the reader with challenging, often hilarious “fashion tips,” dialogues about surgery, and uncomfortable questions. Bornstein doesn’t offer easy answers. Instead, she invites readers to sit in the mess. Since the publication of Gender Outlaw, Bornstein has continued to evolve, and so has her view of gender. She now identifies as non-binary and uses both they/them and she/her pronouns. As she revealed on the LGBTQ&A podcast in 2021, the COVID-19 pandemic and the process of aging brought her to a new perspective: “Gender became inconsequential to me while I was in quarantine and grappling with old age.”
Her candor about aging, illness, and identity has only deepened the philosophical roots of her work.
A survivor of PTSD, anorexia, and lung cancer, Bornstein’s continued presence on stages and in bookstores is both a political and personal triumph. “I’m too old to be cute,” she jokes in the podcast, “but that’s not a tragedy. I let go of that as being necessary to my gender.” Gender Outlaw remains a classic not because it provides a fixed theory of gender but because it refuses to do so. Its legacy lives on in books like Gender Outlaws: The Next Generation (edited with S. Bear Bergman) and My New Gender Workbook, which invites readers into the playful yet radical process of questioning everything they think they know about identity.
At a time when anti-trans rhetoric continues to rise, Bornstein’s work is more relevant than ever. It reminds us that gender is not a threat, but a possibility, a way to be more ourselves, not less.
In The Heroines interview, Bornstein concludes, “I want to help people who are hurting. That’s what I’m here to do. That’s the only thing worth doing.”
Indeed, Gender Outlaw is not just a book, it’s a lifeline, a mirror, a punchline, and a revolution in 224 pages. Whether you’re grappling with your own identity or questioning the ones assigned to others, Bornstein’s work will challenge you to break the laws that never served you in the first place, and write some new ones in their place.
Available via Amazon
and Goodreads
Photo via Heroines of My Life
Post a Comment