In her striking and deeply personal memoir She/Him/Us: A Psychiatrist’s Search for Her Daughter in the Transgender Sea, Dr. Lisa Bellot confronts one of the most emotionally charged issues of our time through the lens of both a psychiatrist and a mother. The book chronicles her journey as she navigates the turbulent waters of her daughter’s sudden identification as transgender, a revelation that forced her to question not only her medical training but also her most intimate instincts as a parent. What emerges is a gripping and reflective narrative that challenges prevailing assumptions about gender identity, the mental health profession, and what it truly means to love and protect one’s child.
Dr. Bellot’s story begins with the shock and confusion that many parents of trans-identified teens experience. As a seasoned psychiatrist with two decades of clinical experience in California, she believed she had seen nearly everything the human mind could present. Yet when her own teenage daughter announced she was trans, Bellot found herself facing an entirely new emotional and moral frontier. She describes the moment with raw vulnerability, not as a detached clinician but as a mother whose world has tilted off its axis. Her initial instinct was not to affirm, but to pause and understand. The question that drives the memoir is not simply whether her daughter is transgender, but how a parent can respond when every cultural, medical, and social current demands unquestioning affirmation while her inner voice insists that something deeper needs to be explored.
Throughout the book, Bellot’s dual identity as both doctor and mother gives her perspective uncommon depth. She writes with clarity about the psychological, developmental, and sociological forces shaping what she calls the “transgender sea”, a metaphor for the overwhelming surge of youth identifying as trans and the powerful social currents pulling families in conflicting directions. Drawing from her professional background, she delves into topics such as adolescent brain development, social contagion, and the influence of online communities on vulnerable youth. Yet she never loses sight of the human heart at the center of it all. Each chapter pulses with love, pain, and the fierce desire to protect her daughter from harm, even as that love leads her to question widely accepted medical protocols.
She/Him/Us is neither a polemic nor a manifesto. Instead, it reads like an emotional excavation, one mother’s attempt to reconcile her training in psychiatry with her maternal intuition. Bellot reveals the anguish of being caught between two worlds: the professional environment where deviation from the gender-affirming approach can bring accusations of bigotry, and the personal world of home, where she watches her child wrestle with confusion and identity. Her tone remains compassionate throughout, even toward those with whom she disagrees. She does not mock or vilify, but she asks difficult questions. What if affirmation without exploration is not always the most loving response? What if the current system, in its eagerness to protect, sometimes silences legitimate concerns? These are the moral and clinical questions she dares to raise, not out of defiance but out of care.
Bellot’s reflections are interspersed with moments of levity and warmth, which offer brief respites from the gravity of her subject. Her humor, often self-deprecating, reminds the reader that behind the psychiatrist’s credentials is a mother trying to navigate adolescence, social media, and the minefield of modern parenting. Her writing style is lucid and accessible, carrying the cadence of a conversation rather than a lecture. She speaks directly to parents who feel bewildered, guilty, or alone, reassuring them that confusion does not equal cruelty, and that love sometimes takes the form of asking hard questions.
The book’s power lies in its honesty. Bellot refuses to sanitize her uncertainty or disguise her fears behind professional jargon. She admits to moments of doubt, frustration, and even despair, yet she also finds hope in connection, dialogue, and an evolving understanding of what her daughter needs most. The memoir’s emotional climax is not a definitive revelation about her daughter’s identity but rather a moment of reconciliation, where mother and child rediscover their bond through openness and mutual respect.
Praise for She/Him/Us has come from both clinicians and readers seeking a more nuanced perspective on gender and parenting. Lisa Marchiano, author of Motherhood and When Kids Say They're Trans, calls it “brimming with compassion, humor, solid information, and most of all, love,” noting that it offers comfort and inspiration to parents facing similar challenges. Psychotherapist Stella O’Malley describes the memoir as “a story of hope and love” that makes a vital contribution to the conversation on gender and mental health. Sasha Ayad, coauthor of When Kids Say They’re Trans, highlights its courage and necessity, praising Bellot for blending personal experience with the psychological insight that many parents crave but rarely find.
Ultimately, She/Him/Us is not a book about ideology but about humanity. It asks readers to look beyond labels and to listen, to themselves, to their children, and to the quiet spaces between certainty and doubt. Dr. Lisa Bellot’s background as a psychiatrist lends intellectual weight to her story, but it is her voice as a mother that gives the book its soul. Her journey is one of love tested and deepened, a reminder that compassion and critical thought are not opposites but allies in the search for truth. For anyone seeking to understand the complex intersection of gender, identity, and family in the modern world, this memoir offers not only insight but also grace.
Dr. Bellot, who has practiced psychiatry in California for more than twenty years, brings both clinical expertise and emotional honesty to her writing. As the mother of two daughters, she writes from a place of deep personal investment and moral courage. She/Him/Us stands as a testament to the enduring bond between parent and child and the profound human need to seek understanding even when the world insists on easy answers.
Available via Amazon
Post a Comment